For property owners and real estate investors exploring property management companies Chicago IL, understanding the hidden costs of owning rental property in this city is essential. Chicago is a strong market, but the numbers only work when you account for the real expenses that impact income, profitability, and long-term success.
At Landmark Property Management, we review deals every day for investors across the Chicago market. Jason Marcordes, our founder, consistently sees the same mistakes in pro formas and investment property assumptions. Many projections look great on paper, but they leave out costs that directly affect net operating income and cash flow.
This blog breaks down the true expenses investors should account for when buying or managing rental property in the city and surrounding suburbs.
Watch our video highlights here:
Chicago Property Management Insights: Why Deals Look Better on Paper Than in Reality
Chicago property management requires a realistic understanding of how buildings here actually operate. Older housing stock, seasonal weather, neighborhood differences, and labor costs all affect the bottom line. Many rental property pro formas underestimate these factors.
A reliable Chicago property manager sees these numbers daily. Our team understands what it really costs to maintain units, pay vendors, manage tenant needs, and keep buildings in compliance. This is where the gap between projections and reality becomes clear.
Property Owners Need Accurate Numbers Before Investing
Property owners often approach us with deals that appear strong initially. But once we perform a deeper market analysis and add accurate turnover costs, repair averages, and operating expenses, the property looks different.
Understanding these costs helps owners:
• Determine if the deal truly supports long-term income
• Avoid surprises in the first year
• Plan for maintenance and reserves
• Ensure profitability across all units
• Protect returns and limit financial risks
A realistic view allows property owners to make decisions confidently.
Turnover Costs Are Higher Than Expected
One of the biggest expenses investors underestimate is turnover. Vacancy is only part of the equation. The real cost includes:
• Repairs
• Painting
• Cleaning
• Small upgrades
• Leasing fees
In many neighborhoods throughout the city, a unit must be refreshed to remain competitive. If a rental property sits for even a few weeks, income drops quickly. Property managers see this daily, which is why we encourage investors to budget for turnover more accurately.
Repairs and Maintenance Are Almost Always Undervalued
Another cost that real estate investors routinely miss is maintenance. Many assume four to five percent of income, but Chicago rental property often lands closer to seven to ten percent depending on neighborhood, tenant base, and building condition.
With older Chicago buildings, weather exposure, plumbing issues, aging electrical, and HVAC maintenance are common. This directly affects income and net operating numbers. A property management company can help you estimate realistic monthly and annual repair costs based on the building’s history and location.
Real Estate Investors Should Underwrite Operating Expenses at Chicago Levels
For multifamily buildings in the Chicago market, operating expenses listed on offering memorandums are often unrealistic. Many show thirty to thirty-five percent. In practice, we see closer to forty to fifty percent depending on:
• Property taxes
• Labor and vendor rates
• Utility costs
• Compliance requirements
• Snow removal and seasonal needs
Real estate investors must account for this percentage difference. A few points can make or break the deal. Using real numbers from management fees, maintenance, and turnover helps determine whether the investment supports long-term cash flow and returns.
Property Managers Can Help Investors Avoid Common Mistakes
Experienced property managers work with a wide range of clients across the city. This gives them insight into actual costs and building performance. When you speak with a management company, you benefit from:
• Accurate maintenance invoices
• Day-to-day tenant interactions
• Vendor relationships
• Neighborhood-specific knowledge
• Transparent management fees
• Realistic expectations for rent and occupancy
Local expertise is essential, especially for investors who live outside the city or suburbs. A strong management company helps ensure the property reaches its potential.
Choosing a Property Management Company in Chicago
When you're selecting a property management company in Chicago, look for teams that specialize in the neighborhoods where you plan to invest. Chicago is diverse, and each area offers unique challenges and opportunities.
A good management company will:
• Communicate clearly
• Provide accurate market analysis
• Support owners with transparent pricing
• Offer services backed by real experience
• Help protect income and profitability
• Manage tenant needs efficiently
Your property management team should feel like a partner, not just a vendor.
Chicago Market Realities: Why Accurate Underwriting Protects Your Investment
The real estate landscape in Chicago is competitive and constantly evolving. Understanding true building costs, management processes, tenant expectations, and neighborhood trends allows investors to make informed decisions.
When you account for turnover, maintenance, property management fees, and local market conditions, you create a more stable rental property that performs well long term.
Management Company Support for Chicago Property Owners and Investors
Landmark Property Management works with both new and experienced investors. Whether you own one unit or a full portfolio, our team provides guidance that helps you maximize value, protect your income, and navigate the challenges of owning rental property in the city.
If you’re interested in a transparent, reliable partner that understands the Chicago market and provides exceptional service, we’d be happy to talk.
Reach out today to talk to a member or our Chicago property management team or a FREE Rental Analysis!
.png)
